Skepticism surrounds Russia's proposed deal with Syria - Action News 5 - Memphis, Tennessee

Skepticism surrounds Russia's proposed deal with Syria

Posted: Updated:
If Syria accepts a cease-fire, there are doubts that rebels would go along. (Source: CNN) If Syria accepts a cease-fire, there are doubts that rebels would go along. (Source: CNN)
  • News from SyriaMore>>

  • Dempsey: If campaign fails, ground troops possible

    Dempsey: If campaign fails, ground troops possible

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 12:02 PM EDT2014-09-16 16:02:03 GMT
    President Barack Obama's strategy to combat Islamic State extremists in Iraq and Syria is being scrutinized in Congress, where the expanded military campaign has broad support but faces skepticism after more...More >>
    The nation's top military leader told Congress on Tuesday he would recommend that the United States consider deploying ground forces to Iraq if President Barack Obama's expanded air campaign to destroy Islamic...More >>
  • Iraqi lawmakers reject picks for interior, defense

    Iraqi lawmakers reject picks for interior, defense

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 11:31 AM EDT2014-09-16 15:31:50 GMT
    Iraqi lawmakers say the country's prime minister has made his decision on the remaining posts in his Cabinet, including the critical positions of interior minister and defense minister.More >>
    Iraq's parliament rejected defense and interior nominees on Tuesday, leaving the crucial ministerial posts unfilled as a U.S.-led coalition intensifies its air campaign against Islamic extremists who have seized a...More >>
  • Kurds in Europe take up arms against IS group

    Kurds in Europe take up arms against IS group

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 11:03 AM EDT2014-09-16 15:03:47 GMT
    Shaho Pirani says he's just a phone call away from leaving his quiet life in Denmark and joining Kurdish forces battling against Islamic State militants in Iraq.More >>
    Shaho Pirani says he's just a phone call away from leaving his quiet life in Denmark and joining Kurdish forces battling against Islamic State militants in Iraq.More >>

(CNN) – With the U.S. backing off its push for military action in Syria, world leaders are watching to see if the Damascus regime will give up its chemical weapons stockpile.

But there's a lot of skepticism out there as well, about whether the proposal is realistic, or feasible.

While officials in Damascus, Tehran and Moscow gushed about a deal that could avert a U.S. military strike on Syria, a virtual avalanche of questions left it smothered in doubt. One Israeli expert said it amounted to a "mission impossible."

"For the moment is seems like a mission impossible, in the conditions in which the Syrian conflict finds itself just now," said Ely Karmon, International Institute for Counter-Terrorism. "First of all, a cease fire between the two forces, then both sides have to withdraw to allow inspectors to come in and verify where the weapons and the facilities are."

Even if Syria accepted a cease-fire, there are serious doubts that the rebels would go along.

"The solution may be a good idea but, and it's a big "but" - the technicalities," said Col. Yoni Fighel, International Institute for Counter-Terrorism. "As much as this offer is tempting on the surface of it, the Russians are not being regarded as honest brokers."

An Israeli research institute has compiled a detailed list of Syria's chemical production sites, five major facilities, but experts say there are dozens more sites and Syria's suspected one thousand tons of chemical agents have been disbursed.

Someone, most likely, the U.N., would have to oversee any operation. But there's even a harsher reality, the timeline.

"It's a very long-term solution, at least in my opinion, taking into account the huge arsenal…at least three to four years," said Karmon.

Remember Iraq. U.N. inspectors spent years searching out Saddam Hussein's chemical stockpile, eventually gathering rockets, artillery and raw chemicals at a sprawling desert site called Mouthanna. Iraq may have had more chemical arms, but the inspectors weren't working in the crossfire of conflict.

Copyright 2013 CNN. All rights reserved.

Powered by WorldNow