An MRI at one hospital could cost hundreds less at another - WMC Action News 5 - Memphis, Tennessee

An MRI at one hospital could cost hundreds less at another

Mitch Brandon has an $8,000 bill for an MRI. Down the road, a different hospital charges $350 for an MRI. (Source: Raycom Media) Mitch Brandon has an $8,000 bill for an MRI. Down the road, a different hospital charges $350 for an MRI. (Source: Raycom Media)
Jeanne Pinder, who runs Clear Health Costs, recommends calling a few hospital and clinics to compare prices on procedures and tests. (Source: Andy Miller/Raycom Media) Jeanne Pinder, who runs Clear Health Costs, recommends calling a few hospital and clinics to compare prices on procedures and tests. (Source: Andy Miller/Raycom Media)

By LEE ZURIK and ERIN SNODGRASS

(RNN) - An MRI - and many other vital health-care procedures - are performed exactly the same way, no matter where a patient receives care. But huge differences can be found when patients receive bills to pay for those tests.

Mitch Brandon found that out the hard way. The Army veteran, 20 years removed from service, wanted to know what was wrong with his back.

"A lot of back pain, stiffness, really impacting my way of life," Brandon says about the pain.

A doctor with the U.S. Veteran's Affairs Administration sent Brandon to Lakeview Regional Medical Center in Covington, LA. for two MRIs in 2016.

Seven months later, Brandon received a bill for those scans, totaling more than $8,000.

"I was quite surprised how large it was," Brandon said.

The VA hasn't yet paid the bill and Brandon is unsure if they will. In the meantime, Lakeview's collection's department is calling him for payment.

But, less than a two-minute drive from Lakeview, there is a different medical center, where an MRI costs $350, a Raycom Media national investigation has found.

"It doesn't make sense," said Jeanne Pinder, who runs Clear Health Costs, a New York-based company that is trying to bring transparency to healthcare. "Nobody has any idea what things cost in healthcare."

Across the country, the cost of medical procedures can vary widely between facilities that, in some cases, are a stone's throw apart, the news' organization's investigation found.

In Richmond, VA., the cost of a lower-back MRI at Virginia Commonwealth University Medical Center is $3,000. At nearby Tuckahoe Orthopedics, the same procedure is $399.

The University of Alabama at Birmingham Hospital charges up to $2,273 for an MRI, but a few blocks away, at American Health Imaging that MRI is $525.

"A $300 MRI and $6,000 MRI, what's the difference? The $6,000 one must be 20 times better, right? Wrong," Pinder said.

Even a simple blood test can vary in price.

In Memphis, the cost of a metabolic panel at Baptist Memorial Hospital is $171. At nearby Quest Diagnostics, the charge is $73.45, almost $100 less.

“We believe in price transparency, and that’s why we have offered a cost estimator tool on our website for the past 10 years. We want our patients to have all the information possible before deciding where to have a procedure so they can make an informed decision,” Memphis Baptist said in a statement.

“Our pricing for procedures depends on a number of factors. One of the biggest advantages we offer is our electronic medical record, Baptist OneCare, which gives patients and their physicians quick and easy access to their medical information ? including test results ? from any computer or mobile device,” the statement concluded.

Pinder said there are ways to save money.

Call two or three clinics or hospitals to compare prices. Ask how much of the cost will be paid by your health-insurance company and what the cost is without insurance. And ask for this information in writing.

After a doctor has recommended a procedure, ask for the CPT code, which is a unique number assigned to every medical test by the American Medical Association. Hospitals and diagnostic facilities are reluctant to release pricing information without the code because it ensures everyone is talking about the same thing. For example, the CPT code for a lower back MRI is different than the one for an upper back MRI.

Ask if the procedure could incur any additional costs. In some cases, a clinic can charge a lab fee, a doctor fee, an anesthesiologist fee and/or a facility fee.

Also talk directly with your health insurance company to find out your out-of-pocket costs after insurance has paid on the claim and deductibles have been factored.

Paying for a procedure at the cash rate will not count toward any deductibles, so it will take longer to reach the insurance company's out-of-pocket maximums during the year.

Pinder's company publishes on its website the prices of medical procedures and offers that information to the public for free.

"I'd like to put myself out of business," Pinder said. "You can't keep this secret forever. You can't."

Patients need to treat health-care procedures as if they are looking for a house, car or TV.

"We're not really programmed to think about shopping for medical care," Pinder said. "But we should be."

Copyright 2018 Raycom News Network. All rights reserved.

  • Latest health & fitness newsLatest health & fitness newsMore>>

  • Parenting of the future: Many embryos, each with DNA profile

    Parenting of the future: Many embryos, each with DNA profile

    Wednesday, April 18 2018 1:23 AM EDT2018-04-18 05:23:15 GMT
    Saturday, April 21 2018 5:56 AM EDT2018-04-21 09:56:53 GMT
    (ASRM via AP). This undated microscope image provided by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine in January 2018 shows a trophectoderm biopsy, in which cells from the outer layer of an embryo that develop into the placenta and amniotic membranes...(ASRM via AP). This undated microscope image provided by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine in January 2018 shows a trophectoderm biopsy, in which cells from the outer layer of an embryo that develop into the placenta and amniotic membranes...

    A prominent biomedical ethics expert predicts that in 20 to 40 years, many parents will choose babies from dozens of embryos, after examining DNA information on each.

    More >>

    A prominent biomedical ethics expert predicts that in 20 to 40 years, many parents will choose babies from dozens of embryos, after examining DNA information on each.

    More >>
  • Warming, not cooling, donated livers may improve transplants

    Warming, not cooling, donated livers may improve transplants

    Wednesday, April 18 2018 2:23 PM EDT2018-04-18 18:23:24 GMT
    Saturday, April 21 2018 5:56 AM EDT2018-04-21 09:56:46 GMT
    (OrganOx via AP). This 2016 photo provided by OrganOx shows Drs. David Nasralla and Annemarie Weissenbacher with the company's metra device holding a liver in Oxford, England. On Wednesday, April 18, 2018, British researchers said that keeping at least...(OrganOx via AP). This 2016 photo provided by OrganOx shows Drs. David Nasralla and Annemarie Weissenbacher with the company's metra device holding a liver in Oxford, England. On Wednesday, April 18, 2018, British researchers said that keeping at least...
    Study suggests warming, not cooling, donated livers may improve organ transplants.More >>
    Study suggests warming, not cooling, donated livers may improve organ transplants.More >>
  • UN health agency: Dengue vaccine shouldn't be used widely

    UN health agency: Dengue vaccine shouldn't be used widely

    Thursday, April 19 2018 10:56 AM EDT2018-04-19 14:56:41 GMT
    Saturday, April 21 2018 5:56 AM EDT2018-04-21 09:56:24 GMT
    The World Health Organization says that the first-ever vaccine for dengue needs to be dealt with in "a much safer way" and mostly given to people previously infected with the disease.More >>
    The World Health Organization says that the first-ever vaccine for dengue needs to be dealt with in "a much safer way" and mostly given to people previously infected with the disease.More >>
Powered by Frankly